You've been offered a job in another city. More money, a bigger title, a fresh start. You've already decided it's a yes, and you just want to run it past a friend. When she raises a concern, you have a quick answer ready. When she raises another, you brush it off. By the end of the conversation, you feel even more certain.

Here's the problem: you never actually tested the decision. You only tested your ability to defend it. A simple habit changes this. It's called steelmanning, which means building the strongest possible case against your own view before you commit. It feels uncomfortable at first. That discomfort is usually where the useful information is.

Strawmen Feel Good

A strawman is a weak version of an opposing argument, one that's easy to knock down. We build them all the time, often without noticing. Someone who doubts your plan to move is "just scared of change." A colleague who prefers a different strategy "hasn't looked at the numbers." Once the other side is reduced to its silliest form, winning feels effortless.

There's a reason this happens. Our brains reward us for feeling right. Hunting for flaws in someone else's position is pleasant. Hunting for flaws in our own is not. So we pick the version of the counterargument we know we can beat, and we stop there. Psychologists call the broader pattern motivated reasoning: thinking that serves the conclusion we already want.

The cost is hidden but real. Every strawman you defeat adds a little to your confidence without adding anything to your accuracy. You end up feeling certain about a decision you've never truly stress-tested. And when reality pushes back, it brings the strong version of the argument you ignored, the one you never prepared for.

Takeaway

Beating a weak argument tells you nothing about whether you're right. Confidence earned against a strawman is borrowed, and reality eventually collects.

Building the Best Case

Steelmanning is the opposite move. Instead of finding the easiest version of the other side to beat, you build the hardest one. Here's a useful test: could someone who holds that view read your version and say, "Yes, that's exactly why I believe it"? If not, you're not there yet.

The process has four steps. First, write your position in one sentence. Second, list who might reasonably disagree. Think of thoughtful people, not cranks. Third, ask what they might know or value that you could be underweighting. Maybe your friend has watched three people take jobs for the money and then regret losing their community. That isn't fear. It's evidence. Fourth, write their case as if you were trying to persuade yourself, using their best reasons rather than their worst.

Two tips make this easier. Assume the other side is as smart as you are. And look for the values behind their position, not just the facts. Most serious disagreements aren't about who's ignorant. They're about different priorities. If you get stuck, ask a real person who disagrees. Then repeat their argument back to them until they agree you've got it right.

Takeaway

The test of a good steelman isn't whether it convinces you. It's whether the other side would sign their name to it.

What You Learn

Once you've built a strong opposing case, one of two things happens. Sometimes your original view survives. That's valuable, because now you hold it for better reasons. You know which concerns are real, which risks to watch, and what would have to be true for you to be wrong. You've earned your confidence instead of assuming it.

Other times, the steelman reveals something you missed. The job offer may look less appealing once you weigh what your friend actually meant: your support network, your partner's career, the cost of starting over. You don't have to flip completely. Often the best result is a revised decision, such as negotiating remote days, delaying the move, or setting a check-in point after six months.

Either way, you come out ahead. Annie Duke describes good decision-makers as people who think in probabilities rather than certainties. Steelmanning moves you from "I'm right" toward "I'm fairly confident, and here's why." It changes your disagreements too. When people feel understood, they listen better, and the conversation becomes about getting it right rather than winning.

Takeaway

Steelmanning can't lose: either your belief gets stronger reasons, or you get a chance to change course before it costs you.

Try this on your next real decision. Write your position in one sentence. Then write the best case against it in a short paragraph, strong enough that its supporters would nod along. Finally, ask: what would have to be true for that case to be right?

Practice on small choices first, like a purchase or a weekend plan. The habit builds quickly. You're not trying to doubt everything. You're just making sure your confidence has been earned.