For much of the twentieth century, early modern historians treated objects the way a printed book treats its engravings: decorative, occasionally revealing, ultimately subordinate to the text. A Delftware tile or a pewter tankard might illustrate an argument about domestic life, but the argument itself was built from sermons, ledgers, and correspondence. The archive was a paper archive, and historical understanding meant the interpretation of written representation.

Since the 1980s, that hierarchy has been steadily, if unevenly, dismantled. Anthropologists such as Arjun Appadurai and Igor Kopytoff proposed that things possess social lives and biographies. Theorists from Alfred Gell to Bruno Latour attributed to them something like agency. Early modernists proved unusually receptive, because their period was defined by unprecedented flows of goods. The result is what is now loosely called the material turn, though its coherence as a single movement is itself open to question.

Yet the turn's very success raises a problem it has not fully resolved. If objects are to be more than illustrations, historians must explain what they can know from them that texts cannot supply, and how they know it. This article traces three phases of that reckoning. The first is the theoretical move beyond representation. The second is the reorientation toward global commodities. The third is the set of methodological doubts that still shadow claims about what objects can tell us.

Beyond Representation: From Illustration to Agency

The first wave of material history in early modern studies did not begin from nothing. Fernand Braudel's The Structures of Everyday Life (1979) had already placed bread, houses, and clothing at the centre of historical analysis. The consumer revolution literature of the 1980s, from McKendrick, Brewer and Plumb to Lorna Weatherill's work on probate inventories, catalogued the multiplication of goods in English households. In both cases, however, objects functioned primarily as data: evidence of prices, distribution, or social emulation.

The decisive theoretical shift came from outside history. Appadurai's edited volume The Social Life of Things (1986) argued that commodity status was a phase in an object's career rather than an intrinsic property. Kopytoff's essay in the same volume proposed tracing the cultural biography of things. On this account, meaning was not stamped onto objects by their producers. It accumulated through exchange, use, and reuse. Historians thereby gained a framework for following a single object across successive contexts.

A more radical claim followed. Gell's Art and Agency (1998) treated artefacts as indices through which agency is distributed among persons. Latour's actor-network theory refused any a priori distinction between human and non-human actors. Jane Bennett's Vibrant Matter (2010) went further still, toward a thing-power irreducible to human intention. Early modernists drew selectively on these positions to argue that clocks, instruments, and printed books did not merely reflect transformation but helped to produce it.

The history of science offered the most productive test case. Pamela Smith's The Body of the Artisan (2004) located important roots of experimental knowledge in artisanal engagement with materials. The Making and Knowing Project that followed reconstructed recipes from a sixteenth-century French workshop manuscript, recovering forms of knowledge that resisted full textual expression. Here objects and materials were not illustrations of an epistemology. They were its very medium, and their behaviour under the hand shaped what practitioners came to know.

Still, the language of agency has attracted justified scepticism. Critics note that strong versions risk anthropomorphism, or an evasion of human responsibility. That concern sharpens when the things in question embody coerced labour, as early modern sugar and cotton so often did. Tim Ingold's call to attend to materials rather than an abstract materiality offers a corrective. Perhaps the point is less that objects act than that their physical properties constrain and enable what humans can do with them.

Takeaway

The most defensible claim of the material turn is not that objects think, but that their physical properties shape what becomes thinkable: agency understood as constraint and affordance rather than intention.

Global Goods: Commodities and the Making of Connection

If the agency debate supplied theory, the global turn supplied subject matter. Porcelain, cotton textiles, tobacco, chocolate, sugar, and silver crossed oceans in quantities and at speeds without precedent. Following them offered a way to write global history that avoided both Eurocentric narrative and abstract world-systems analysis. Sidney Mintz's Sweetness and Power (1985) had shown how a single commodity could bind Caribbean plantation labour to English working-class diets. Later scholars extended the method across a widening range of goods.

Timothy Brook's Vermeer's Hat (2008) exemplifies the genre's appeal. Brook treated objects in Delft paintings, such as a beaver-felt hat and a Chinese dish, as doorways into seventeenth-century networks. These networks linked the North American fur trade, Dutch shipping, and Ming production. The method persuaded precisely because it was concrete. The global was not merely asserted. It was traced through particular things and the routes that delivered them to a Dutch interior.

More consequential, perhaps, was the revision of how goods changed as they moved. Marcy Norton's work on chocolate challenged the long-standing assumption that Europeans adopted American goods only after Europeanising them with sugar and spices. Drawing on Spanish colonial sources, she argued that colonists acquired Mesoamerican tastes and practices of consumption. This inverted the presumed direction of cultural influence. Objects became evidence of European receptivity to Indigenous aesthetics, not simply of European appropriation and transformation.

Textiles and ceramics generated comparable revisions. Giorgio Riello's Cotton (2013) placed Indian manufacturing at the centre of a global economy that Britain later imitated. Studies of Chinese porcelain, including Robert Finlay's The Pilgrim Art (2010), traced motifs moving between Jingdezhen, the Islamic world, and Europe. Imitation, in the form of Delftware, printed calicoes, and Meissen, emerged as a central mechanism of early modern innovation rather than a derivative footnote to European ingenuity.

The approach nonetheless carries its own distortions. Commodity biographies tend to privilege goods that travelled well and left records, foregrounding merchants and consumers over producers. The vocabulary of connection and circulation can also aestheticise violence, since the flow of goods was frequently secured by coercion, monopoly, and enslavement. The most careful recent work, including the essays in Anne Gerritsen and Riello's The Global Lives of Things (2016), attends to friction, disjunction, and failure as well as movement.

Takeaway

Following a thing across oceans can decentre Europe, but it can also make violence look like circulation. The question worth asking is always whose hands the object passed through, and on what terms.

Methodological Challenges: Reading Objects Without Words

The material turn's foundational promise was access to experiences that texts omit: the illiterate, the domestic, the tacit. Leora Auslander's 2005 essay "Beyond Words" in the American Historical Review argued that historians had been excessively logocentric. They had missed forms of expression that were embodied and material. Yet the practical question remains stubborn. In the absence of a text, how does one move from describing an object to making a defensible historical claim about it?

Jules Prown's method, developed for American decorative arts, offered one answer. Interpretation proceeds from careful description, through deduction about sensory and functional engagement, to speculation about cultural meaning. The sequence disciplines interpretation, but critics observe that its final stage often brings textual knowledge back in. The historian's sense of what a chair or a ewer meant is rarely derived from the object alone. It is triangulated against inventories, prescriptive literature, and correspondence.

This dependence is not incidental. Much celebrated early modern material history rests on documents about objects rather than objects themselves: probate inventories, customs records, merchants' letters. Renata Ago's study of seventeenth-century Roman possessions, for example, reconstructs relationships with things largely through notarial sources. Such work is valuable, but it raises a fair question. Is this a history of material culture, or a history of how literate institutions recorded, valued, and classified it?

Survival bias compounds the problem. Museums preserve what was prized, durable, and collected: silver over earthenware, embroidered silk over worn linen, the cabinet over the stool. Ordinary objects were used up, recycled, or discarded. Archaeology partially corrects this imbalance, and collaborations with archaeologists and conservators have multiplied. Yet the populations the material turn most hoped to recover are often the least represented in surviving collections, many of which were themselves assembled through colonial acquisition.

None of this invalidates the enterprise; it specifies its terms. Objects seldom speak without textual mediation, but they can correct, complicate, and occasionally contradict what texts claim. A worn handle, an unexpected repair, or a technical analysis of pigments can reveal patterns of use that no inventory recorded. The material and the textual are best understood not as rival archives competing for primacy, but as mutually interrogating ones, each exposing the silences of the other.

Takeaway

Objects are rarely mute witnesses that speak for themselves; their evidentiary power often lies in their capacity to contradict the documents that describe them.

Four decades on, the material turn is less a turn than an established orientation. Few early modernists now treat objects merely as illustrations, and the global history of commodities has become one of the field's most productive genres. The theoretical maximalism of strong agency claims, however, has largely given way to more modest language of affordance, mediation, and entanglement.

The most promising directions lie in method rather than manifesto. They include the reconstruction of historical techniques, scientific analysis of materials, and closer collaboration with archaeologists and conservators. They also include sustained attention to objects by non-elite and non-European makers held in collections built by colonial powers.

The deeper question the turn poses is historiographical. Every generation finds in the past the evidence its theories prepare it to see. The material turn has taught historians to notice things. Its next task is to examine how its own frameworks decide which things count, and which remain invisible.