In April 2018, Lil Miquela's Instagram account appeared to be hijacked by another virtual influencer, Bermuda, who threatened to expose Miquela's true nature. What followed was a confession: Miquela was not a human girl but a robot built by a company called Brud. Her followers responded with grief, outrage and sympathy. Yet nothing essential had been hidden from them. Miquela had always been visibly computer-generated. The reveal of an artificial origin inside an already artificial character still produced real emotional turbulence.

This is a strange aesthetic event. Traditional categories separate the artwork from its maker, and the fiction from the performer who embodies it. Virtual influencers collapse these distinctions. Miquela, Imma, Shudu and Noonoouri are not characters in a story we choose to visit. They post, comment, endorse products and appear in our feeds alongside our friends. They are fictions that occupy the grammar of personhood, speaking in the first person to an audience that answers back.

Walter Benjamin argued that mechanical reproduction stripped artworks of their aura, the unique presence rooted in a particular time and place. Virtual influencers suggest a stranger inversion: an aura manufactured without any original at all. To understand them, we need to examine how they are designed, why we form attachments to them, and how we might evaluate them critically. Simply consuming them misses the point. So does dismissing them as marketing gimmicks.

Designed Personalities: Interiority as Interface

A virtual influencer is not a single artwork but an ongoing production. Behind Miquela sit 3D artists, writers, social strategists and brand managers. Every pore, freckle and slightly gapped tooth is a decision. Shudu was created by photographer Cameron-James Wilson in 2017. She was modelled with such attention to skin texture and studio lighting that many viewers first assumed she was a real woman. Realism here is not a byproduct of the work. It is the medium itself.

Surface realism alone does not make an influencer, however. These figures differ from digital mannequins because they simulate interiority: moods, opinions, memories and vulnerability. Miquela posts about breakups, supports causes, releases music and admits insecurity. These are narrative devices borrowed from the confessional register of human influencers. That register was already a performance of authenticity. The virtual version simply makes the staging explicit.

Vilém Flusser described the technical image as a surface that encodes concepts rather than depicting the world. Virtual influencers are technical images in this precise sense. Their apparent selfhood is a program, a set of parameters calibrated for engagement. The character's personality is less an expression than an interface. It is a layer designed to make a commercial apparatus feel approachable, relatable and even lovable.

This produces a distinctive aesthetic tension. We are invited to appreciate both the craft of the rendering and the illusion of a self, and these two modes of attention pull against each other. Admiring Imma's hyperreal pink bob as a technical achievement means stepping outside the fiction. Responding to her posts as if she were a person means stepping back in. The experience oscillates between connoisseurship and companionship, never settling fully into either.

Crucially, the designed personality is never finished. A novel's protagonist has an interiority that is fixed once the book is published. A virtual influencer accumulates character in real time, responding to metrics and market conditions. Its self is iterative, A/B tested and revised according to what audiences reward. The aesthetic object, then, is not the image alone. It is the feedback loop that continuously reshapes the image according to collective response.

Takeaway

A virtual influencer's personality is best understood not as a fictional self but as an interface: a designed surface that makes an apparatus feel like a someone.

Attachment Without a Person

In 1956, the sociologists Donald Horton and Richard Wohl coined the term parasocial interaction. It described the one-sided intimacy audiences felt toward television personalities. The host looked into the camera, addressed viewers directly and simulated conversation. Viewers responded as if a relationship existed. Social media intensified this structure with comments, replies and stories that feel addressed to you personally. Virtual influencers inherit this whole architecture while removing its final element: the human on the other side.

Strikingly, this removal seems to matter less than one might expect. Parasocial bonds appear to depend on perceived responsiveness and consistency, not on verified existence. The mind reaches for what Daniel Dennett called the intentional stance. We attribute beliefs and desires to whatever behaves as if it has them. A character who remembers earlier storylines, reacts to events and keeps a recognisable voice activates the same social machinery as a friend who does the same.

Philosophers have long wrestled with the paradox of fiction: how can we feel genuine emotion toward people we know do not exist? Kendall Walton answered that we play games of make-believe and experience quasi-emotions within an imaginative frame. Virtual influencers complicate this account because the frame keeps dissolving. They appear between posts from your sister and news headlines. There is no book cover or theatre curtain to mark where the fiction begins.

A subtler mechanism is also at work. Human influencers carry the risk of disappointment: scandals, ageing, inconsistency, a private self that contradicts the persona. Virtual influencers offer a parasocial object without that friction. They never have a bad day unless the narrative calls for one. This reliability may be part of their appeal. It offers an attachment purified of the unpredictability that makes real relationships both difficult and meaningful.

Here Benjamin's concept of aura returns in altered form. The aura once depended on authentic presence, the here and now of the original. The virtual influencer manufactures presence through continuity and direct address, producing the sensation that someone is there. What audiences attach to is not a person but the felt quality of being attended to. That quality, it turns out, can be engineered with remarkable precision.

Takeaway

Parasocial attachment never required a real person; it required the sensation of being addressed. Virtual influencers reveal how much of intimacy is structure rather than substance.

Toward a Critical Aesthetics of Synthetic Fame

Dismissal is the easiest response to virtual influencers: they are marketing with a face and nothing more. Uncritical enthusiasm is the second easiest: they are the future of creativity. Neither stance helps us evaluate them. A more productive approach treats them as hybrid works, part character, part campaign and part performance art. It then asks which aesthetic criteria actually apply to such objects.

The first framework concerns transparency of construction. The most interesting virtual influencers make their artificiality part of the work rather than a secret. Whatever its commercial motives, Miquela's 2018 robot reveal turned the question of her nature into narrative material. Hatsune Miku, the Vocaloid character from Crypton Future Media, thrives because her synthetic voice and fan-made songs are openly celebrated. Concealment flattens the aesthetic. Acknowledgement deepens it.

The second framework concerns authorship and accountability. Who speaks when a virtual influencer speaks? In 2019, Miquela appeared in a Calvin Klein campaign kissing Bella Hadid. The backlash raised questions about corporations borrowing queer representation through a body that could bear no consequences. Evaluating these works requires tracing the voice back through the apparatus, to the studio, the brand and the client. It also means asking whose interests the persona ultimately serves.

The third framework concerns representation. Shudu drew criticism because a white creator profited from a digital Black woman while real Black models faced exclusion in the fashion industry. Synthetic bodies are not neutral. They encode choices about race, gender, beauty and desirability, and no actual person constrains those choices. The freedom to design anything makes every design decision more telling, not less.

Finally, we can ask what aesthetic experience these works enable that nothing else could. At their best, virtual influencers stage the performance of selfhood that all social media demands. They make visible the constructedness that human influencers disguise, and so act as mirrors held up to the platform itself. At their worst, they simply perfect the machinery of attention capture. The difference often lies in whether the work invites reflection or forecloses it.

Takeaway

Judge a virtual influencer as you would any hybrid artwork: by how honestly it shows its construction, whom it speaks for, and whether it makes the surrounding system more visible or less.

Virtual influencers are often framed as a novelty, a curious footnote to the creator economy. They are better understood as a stress test for aesthetic theory. They separate the felt presence of a person from the existence of one. In doing so, they expose how much of our digital intimacy was already built from design, repetition and address.

Generative AI is making synthetic personas cheap to produce and capable of real-time conversation, and these questions will multiply. The influencer who posts is becoming the companion who replies. The aesthetic and ethical stakes of simulated interiority will move from public feeds into private exchanges, where the frame of fiction is even harder to see.

Benjamin feared the loss of aura, and Flusser warned that we risk becoming functionaries of our apparatuses. Virtual influencers sit where both concerns meet. The task for artists and critics is not to refuse them. It is to insist that synthetic presence be read as carefully as any image, with attention to who built it and why.