A senior manager sits through a meeting where a peer quietly takes apart her project. She nods, takes notes, and calls it a reasonable direction. Afterward, she can barely recall what was decided. That evening, she snaps at her partner over something trivial. By any conventional measure, she handled the meeting professionally.
Most workplaces reward this kind of composure. We learn early that frustration, disappointment, and even enthusiasm should be kept in check. The ideal professional, we're told, is calm, neutral, and difficult to read. Emotions are treated as noise that gets in the way of rational work, so we keep them out of sight.
Research on emotion regulation tells a more complicated story. Suppression is not neutral. It uses up mental resources, strains the body, and slowly erodes trust between colleagues. The real question isn't whether emotions belong at work, because they're already in every meeting and every decision. The question is how to bring them in skillfully instead of pretending they don't exist.
What Suppression Actually Costs
Psychologist James Gross distinguishes between two broad ways of managing emotions. Reappraisal changes how you interpret a situation before the emotional response fully forms. Suppression works later. The feeling arrives, and you clamp down on what shows on the outside. The emotion is still there. You've just hidden it. The two strategies lead to very different results.
The first cost is cognitive. In laboratory studies, people asked to suppress their emotional reactions remembered less of what happened during the task. Keeping a poker face is active work, and it uses the same attention you need to listen, reason, and retain information. The manager who can't recall what was decided in a tense meeting wasn't distracted. She was busy managing her face.
The second cost is physical. Suppression doesn't reduce the internal experience of emotion. Studies have found it can actually increase stress-related arousal in the body. Arlie Hochschild coined the term emotional labor for managing feelings as part of a job. Research in this area links persistent "surface acting," which means displaying emotions you don't feel, with exhaustion and burnout. Over months and years, the gap between what you feel and what you show becomes a chronic stressor.
The third cost affects relationships, and it's the one leaders most often miss. In one study, people talking with a partner who had been told to suppress their emotions felt less rapport, and their own blood pressure rose. Suppression is contagious. Colleagues sense that something is being held back, even if they can't name it, and they start holding back too. A team of composed individuals can become a team where nobody quite trusts what anyone else is thinking.
TakeawaySuppression doesn't remove an emotion. It moves the cost into your attention, your body, and the relationships around you.
Which Expressions Help and Which Hurt
If suppression is costly, venting everything isn't the answer either. Some emotional expressions strengthen working relationships, and others damage them. The useful line isn't between positive and negative emotions. It's between expressions that share information and expressions that push pressure onto others.
Productive expressions tend to have three features. They match the size of the situation. They take ownership instead of assigning blame, as in "I'm concerned this timeline puts quality at risk" rather than "You've set us up to fail." And they point toward something people can act on. Concern, disappointment, and even frustration can be valuable when they tell colleagues what matters to you and why. A leader who says "I'm worried about this client relationship" gives the team information they can use.
Problematic expressions usually fail at least one of those tests. Contempt is especially damaging, whether it shows up as eye-rolling, sarcasm, or a dismissive tone, because it signals that the other person isn't worth engaging with. Anger from someone with positional power can silence a room, whatever the intent. Chronic complaining with no direction spreads frustration without giving anyone a way to fix the problem. These expressions don't inform people. They unload on them.
Peter Salovey and John Mayer's model of emotional intelligence helps here. It has four branches: perceiving, using, understanding, and managing emotions. Together they suggest that skilled expression starts well before you speak. You notice the feeling, work out what it's signaling, and decide how it can help the conversation. In this view, managing emotions doesn't mean muting them. It means directing them so they carry their message without overwhelming the people who hear it. Power changes the equation too. The more authority you hold, the louder your emotions land.
TakeawayBefore you express a strong feeling at work, ask whether it gives others information they can use or simply passes your pressure on to them.
Building Authentic Professional Presence
Authenticity at work doesn't mean saying everything you feel. It means that what you do show is genuinely connected to what you experience. People are remarkably good at sensing a gap between the emotion someone displays and the one underneath. That gap, more than the emotion itself, is what tends to damage credibility.
One practical approach is to name emotions at a measured level. You don't have to choose between showing raw frustration and hiding it completely. You can acknowledge it calmly: "I'll be honest, I'm frustrated that we're revisiting this decision. Let me explain why it matters to me." This keeps the emotion visible without letting it take over the conversation. Research on affect labeling suggests that putting feelings into words can itself make them less intense.
A second approach is to rely less on suppression and more on reappraisal. Instead of clamping down on a reaction in the middle of a meeting, experienced leaders often reframe situations ahead of time. A tough question from a board member becomes a chance to strengthen the proposal rather than an attack. Researchers call this deep acting, which means genuinely adjusting how you feel rather than only how you appear. It carries far fewer costs than putting on a performance.
Finally, authentic presence belongs to the whole team, not just to individuals. When leaders show measured emotional honesty, they widen what others feel safe expressing. Amy Edmondson's research on psychological safety shows that teams learn and perform better when people can raise concerns without fear. Emotional honesty and psychological safety reinforce each other. A leader who admits uncertainty gives others permission to flag problems early, before they become expensive.
TakeawayAuthenticity isn't full disclosure. It's a match between what you feel and what you choose to show.
Composure has real value at work. But composure built on constant suppression is expensive. It costs attention, health, and the trust that teams depend on.
Three strategies can help. First, after a difficult interaction, notice what you held back and what that feeling was telling you. Second, practice naming one emotion each week in calm, ownership language, such as "I'm concerned," "I'm encouraged," or "I'm frustrated about this specific thing." Third, prepare for predictable flashpoints by reframing them in advance instead of gritting your teeth through them.
The goal isn't a more emotional workplace. It's a more honest one, where feelings carry useful information instead of pressure, and where nobody has to spend half their attention managing their face.