Picture a Monday morning on a college campus in the 1970s. The weekend's football game is over, and the result is already written across people's chests. Walk across the quad after a win and you'll see a sea of school colors: sweatshirts, caps, and scarves proudly bearing the university name. Walk the same path after a loss and the logos have quietly gone into hiding, as if the whole student body had agreed to wear plain gray.
None of these students threw a pass or made a tackle. Yet their wardrobes rose and fell with the scoreboard. Psychologists call this BIRGing, or basking in reflected glory. Its shy cousin is CORFing, or cutting off reflected failure. Together they show how stretchy our sense of self really is.
Monday Morning Sweatshirts
In 1976, psychologist Robert Cialdini and his colleagues decided to treat college fashion as data. They sent observers into large introductory psychology classes at seven universities with serious football programs, including Ohio State, Notre Dame, Michigan, and USC. On the Monday after each game, the observers quietly tallied how many students were wearing clothing that announced their school.
The pattern was hard to miss. After the team won, more students showed up in university-branded gear. After a loss, fewer did. Nobody had organized this. There was no campus-wide email urging everyone to show school spirit. Thousands of people independently reached into their closets and made the same quiet calculation.
What makes the finding so charming is how trivial the behavior seems. Choosing a sweatshirt hardly feels like a statement about identity, and that is exactly why it's revealing. When we aren't thinking hard, our choices drift toward whatever makes us look good by association. A logo is a little flag planted on the body that says I'm with them. We're far more eager to plant it when 'them' has just covered itself in glory. The students weren't pretending to be someone else. They were simply turning the volume up and down on one part of who they were, depending on how flattering it happened to be that day.
TakeawayOur identities work less like fixed badges and more like dimmer switches. We brighten the connections that flatter us and dim the ones that don't, often before we've consciously decided anything.
The Telling Pronoun
Cialdini didn't stop at sweatshirts. In a follow-up study, researchers phoned students and asked them to describe the outcome of a recent game. Then they listened, not to the details of the game, but to the pronouns. After a win, students were noticeably more likely to say we, as in 'we won.' After a loss, the language tended to shift to they, as in 'they lost.'
Here's the twist. Before some of the calls, students took a short quiz and were told they had done poorly. Those whose egos had just taken a bruise were even more likely to reach for 'we' after a victory. A small personal failure made borrowed success look especially appealing. The pronoun wasn't just grammar. It was a life raft.
You've heard this at every office party. The big new client becomes 'our deal,' while the botched product launch becomes something 'management' did. Parents talk about 'our' straight-A kid and, on a rougher week, ask the other parent what 'your son' has done now. The remarkable part is that almost no one notices the switch. We don't sit down and decide to edit our pronouns. They simply slide toward the winning side, like water finding the lowest point in the floor, and we hear only the story we wanted to tell.
TakeawayListen to your own pronouns for a week. The moments you slip from 'we' to 'they' form a surprisingly honest map of where you want credit and where you want distance.
Borrowed Self-Esteem
Why would anyone feel proud of something they had nothing to do with? Part of the answer comes from social identity theory, developed by psychologist Henri Tajfel. The idea is simple: a slice of who we are comes from the groups we belong to, whether that's a school, a city, a country, or a team. When the group rises, that slice of us rises with it. It's self-esteem held in a joint account.
This explains some wonderfully odd behavior. Towns put up signs announcing that a famous actor was born there, decades after the actor left and never looked back. People feel a flicker of pride when someone from their country wins a Nobel Prize in a field they can't pronounce. In one study, people who learned they shared a birthday with the notorious Rasputin rated him a bit more favorably. A coincidence of the calendar was enough to make him feel slightly like 'one of us.'
The joint account has a downside, of course. If our worth rides on the group, then a loss feels like a personal withdrawal, which is exactly why we're so quick to CORF and step away. But there's something tender here too. We're built to rise and fall together. The same instinct that makes us claim a stranger's touchdown also lets us feel a stranger's grief.
TakeawayA surprising share of your self-worth isn't stored in you alone but in the groups you belong to, which makes caring about others' success less purely selfless, and more deeply human, than it looks.
Next time your team wins, notice how easily 'we' rolls off your tongue. Notice, too, how quickly it becomes 'they' when the season turns sour. It isn't hypocrisy. It's a mind quietly managing its reputation, one sweatshirt and one pronoun at a time.
The edges of the self are more flexible than we think. We stretch them to include winners and pull them in to escape losers. Knowing that won't stop you from wearing the jersey. But it might make you smile when you do.